Thursday, January 9, 2014

IVF Babies at Enhanced Risk. But Why, and So What?

This Australian study in PLOS One shows significant risk of health problems in babies born from assisted conception as opposed to spontaneous conceptions. Compared to spontaneously-conceived singletons, singletons from assisted conception were almost twice as likely to be stillborn, more than twice as likely to be pre-term, almost three times as likely to have very low birth weight, and twice as likely to die within the first four weeks after birth. Outcomes varied by type of assisted conception. Very low and low birth weight, very preterm and preterm birth, and neonatal death were "markedly" more common in births from IVF and, to a lesser degree, in births from ICSI. Use of frozen embryos elminated the risks of ICSI, but not of IVF. But frozen embryos also had increased risk of macrosomia.

The study mentions, but doesn't linger on, data showing that kids spontaneously born of parents with untreated infertility problems also have adverse outcomes compared to kids of non-infertile parents. Compared to spontaneously conceived children of women with no infertility problems, spontaneously conceived children of women with infertility problems were nine times more likely to have very low birth weight, seven times more likely to be very pre-term, and almost seven times more likely to die within the first 28 days of birth. Some experts say that this may mean that the problems experienced by children of assisted reproduction may be more due to parental infertility than to infertility treatment.

Let us leave aside the possibility that many or most IVF-related risks are really just infertility-related risks. The sort of data discussed in this study always brings to my mind some variations on the "non-identity" problem invented by Derek Parfit. Suppose a child of IVF is born with low birthweight, and experiences lifelong significant complications which were foreseeable by the parents when they decided to used IVF. Has that child any complaint against the parents? One possible answer is, "No, because the condition of the possibility of that particular child's ever existing at all was his or her parents' use of the IVF which caused both his or her existence and his or her low birthweight. Only a child whose life was so wretched as to literally not be worth living could complain about his or her parents' use of IVF." The argument in this form seems sound but it also troubles me, because (for example) one can easily imagine the circumstances in which one might accurately say to a slave, "You have no right to complain about being born a slave, because without the institution of slavery, you would never have been born at all."

If IVF is risky, and a child of IVF is born with a disability, and the child would not have been born without IVF, what sort of complaint can one mount, from the child's point of view, about the disability?


  1. Article contains so many fruitful information which will be liked by the readers as in my opinion
    this is the best article in this category.
    Gynecologist mountain view, ca

  2. IVF does not always work the first time and may not work at all for some patients.Reactions to Fertility Drugs.IVF increases the risk of multiple births if more than one embryo is implanted in your uterus. A pregnancy with multiple fetuses carries a higher risk of early labor and low birth weight than pregnancy with a single fetus does.

  3. If you are looking for a true companion, don’t look otherwise as I am taniya bamhotra, a 22-year-old Escort in Dehradun, providing emotional intimacy, mental stimulation and psychological support to my clients. Sure, I look excellent and great in a bikini but that’s just the tip of the iceberg. I will not be pigeon-holed as a sex-object. I am a high class call girl/Independent Dehradun Escorts, who creates a very deep and special connections with my gentlemen clients.

    I consider them as my friends and opposed to any idea of merely providing sexual services. But, I also promptly forget the last encounter as I move on to the next one with equal energy level. I meet fewer dates at high levels and thus not easily available to everybody. This retains my exclusivity and freshness. This is exactly the high-end customers seek and pay for. I am an authentic person and not a common sex worker. I prefer meeting equally sophisticated gentlemen, so that I get exposed exclusively before only tasteful, mutual engaging persons. So, those who mistake me as a red-light girl or even a blow-up doll, need to stay away. At the higher end of the industry, there are some conditions and unwritten terms, which I follow religiously. I am a trust-worthy girl, who do not believe only in providing sexual pleasures.

    dehradun escorts

    mussoorie escorts

    call girls in dehradun

    Rishikesh escort

    call girls in rishikesh

    rajpur road escorts

    mallroad escorts

    premnagar escorts

    ballupur escorts

    Not every woman is suited to this elite world, and not every woman has it, what it needs to be a good escort. Much like the modelling industry, this industry is based on overall looks. It is the first and the foremost condition to be a successful Dehradun Escorts. I am a sweet, beautiful girl, with elegant personality. My body is amazing and my choosen dresses further add volumes to my impressive personality. I am fresh faced, classically beautiful with a flawless complexion. I have pleasant facial features. Much like super models, I am a blank canvass, to be able to cater the preferences and needs of the clients.

    I have imposed a self-restriction on tattoos. My hair style is main-stream, which suits me a lot. Lavender or pink or red hair is good and all well in the personal life but not in this profession. I am facially and surface-image wise, classic beauty. My clients always tell, how much beautiful I am, and they also praise my friendly and supportive attitude. I have undergone a short conservative cosmetic surgery as I understand that too much work may ruin my looks. For me natural beauty is imperitive and I strictly avoid any overdone work, fillers etc. You can fine more stunning girls like me on Dehradun Call Girls group. If you are interested for some naughty game and planning for threesome, I am ready to accommodate. I love such plays, as when you will be loving one girl, other will be fondling you.


  4. I think this is a really good article. You make this information interesting and engaging. You give readers a lot to think about and I appreciate that kind of writing. Fertility treatment in Spain